Hi, I'm Crissi Matthews

As natural born entrepreneur, I’ve owned, sold, succeeded, and failed at many businesses. I’ve had multiple e-commerce businesses selling things from household items to gifts to trinkets, bought and sold heavy equipment through auctions, had a pet-sitting business, and the list goes on. None of these brought as much excitement and bliss as watching a family close on their next home! What accomplishment could bring more happiness than seeing tears of joy run down a families face as they receive the keys to the place they’ll now call HOME?!

Over the past 11 years, I’ve become a self-proclaimed real estate junkie who lives and breathes all things property related. I’ve spent these years focusing on familiarizing myself with every fact of real estate. Within the realm of the property world, I’ve flipped, wholesaled, lease optioned, and acquired a small portfolio of my own rentals. I am a progressive and forward-thinking Realtor with my approach to home sales, home buying, leasing, and new construction. My creativity and persistence benefit you as my client and I will utilize all of my skills to facilitate your transaction effectively and efficiently. I can be trusted to identify the best deal for you and your family. When you enlist me as your agent, you’ll directly benefit from the experience and expertise I will put to work for you.

Introducing Amy, our newest member of the real estate team! With an impressive 23-year tenure at The Department of Defense as a project manager, Amy brings a wealth of experience and dedication to her role. Transitioning to the Department of Homeland Security in 2023, Amy continues her unwavering commitment to service and excellence. Now, Amy will continue that commitment to her clients through her service as a realtor.

Amy’s passion for working with veterans shines through her work. Having obtained her Military Relocation Professional (MRP) certificate, she is equipped with the knowledge and expertise to assist military members facing the unique challenges of relocation. Amy’s dedication to serving those who have served our country is truly inspiring.

Outside of her professional endeavors, Amy finds joy in family life. She resides in Fishers with her husband Tim, celebrating five years of marriage. Together, they have a blended family of six children ranging from ages 21 to 25. Their bond extends beyond the home, as they share the thrill of riding their tandem bike and enthusiastically support Tim’s involvement with the 5th and 6th grade football teams, The Knights.

Amy and Tim’s commitment to their community doesn’t stop there. They actively participate in facilitating Divorce Care classes through their church, providing invaluable support to individuals navigating the challenging process of divorce. With her blend of experience, compassion, and dedication, Amy is a valuable asset to our real estate team, ready to serve clients with integrity and professionalism.

What they say about me

Client Testimonials

Char Young
2 days ago
As a first-time homebuyer, I couldn't be more thankful to have the best realtor help me with finding a home. Crissi went above and beyond to guide me through the entire process. She was patient and always available to answer any questions or concerns that I had at any... read more
Emily Trobe
4 weeks ago
My boyfriend and I had been discussing buying a home for a few months before reaching out to Crissi. It was when my friend bought her first house with her partner that I started working harder to achieve that! We had previously reached out to a different realtor before connecting... read more
Jeremy Bolt
1 month ago
As a real estate professional for 25 years, I have worked with many top Realtors. Crissi Matthews is one of the best real estate agents I have ever worked with. She embodies the spirit of what it means to be a Realtor. Not only does she go above and beyond... read more
Michelle Murphy
2 months ago
Worked with Crissi on selling my moms home. Was a good experience and I was able to do most of it instead of my mom.
kaitlyn jackson
2 months ago
Crissi was amazing with our home buying process and made it so much less stressful. She was very efficient and stayed on top of everything! I will continue to use her for any home purchases that I may have in the future.
2 months ago
My partner and I recently worked with Crissie to purchase our first home and I cannot recommend her enough! She took a stressful process and made it as simple as possible by communicating throughly , quickly, and professionally ! She was kind and patient with any questions that we had,... read more
Zach Welch
4 months ago
Crissi helped my wife and I buy our first home together. She was responsive regarding our interests and setting up showings quickly. When we found the house we wanted to buy, she worked was a great help in getting us what we needed to get the deal done!
Elizabeth Bokel
4 months ago
Crissi is a great realtor. She helped sell my condo that I had lived in for 10 years. It was a bittersweet process and she made it as smooth as possible. She was prompt with her communication and took the time to walk me through every step. I appreciate Crissi... read more
Steve Wolsiffer
6 months ago
My wife and I choose Crissi based on a recommendation and positive experience from our Daughter. Initially we were utilizing Crissi to help us find our retirement home. This presented a major challenge for us as we were being very selective, and the housing market was booming. After over a... read more