Luxury Homes for Sale in Bay Creek at Geist, McCordsville, IN

Bay Creek at Geist is a charming residential community in McCordsville, Indiana, just a few minutes away from Geist Reservoir.

Residential properties were built between 2001 and 2007, and homes for sale in Bay Creek, McCordsville, IN, feature varied styles and sizes to fit different needs and preferences. One of the highlights of living here is the Bay Creek community house and all the amenities within. Dip in the sparkling community pool, play hoops on basketball courts, have your kids enjoy the afternoons at the playground, and enjoy the views as you stroll along the walking trails. For a next-level getaway, residents have easy access to Geist Reservoir, where they can enjoy exciting water activities such as boating, fishing, and swimming. The neighborhood is close to several golf courses, providing endless opportunities to perfect your swing. Flat Fork Creek Park and Bee Camp Creek Nature Preserve are also nearby, offering additional options for outdoor recreation.

FANTASTIC LOCATION: Bay Creek at Geist, McCordsville, IN, homes are near all the best shopping and dining options that Geist and Fishers offer. Plenty of popular attractions and stores within a short drive make it easy to enjoy a night out or get some shopping done. Downtown Fishers is a 15-minute ride, allowing residents to experience unique cultural and entertainment opportunities. Have a fun day with the family, a memorable night with friends, or a peaceful retreat in the beautiful natural setting of the neighborhood.

WATER RECREATION: Geist Reservoir is the second-largest artificial lake in Indiana, encompassing several counties, including Hancock. Although the government initially constructed the dam as a water system, it later developed this into an attraction where residents and guests may enjoy a variety of watersports. Bay Creek, McCordsville, IN, is an 8-minute drive to the best boating and fishing experience. Consider signing up with Indianapolis Yacht Club and meeting people with the same interests. You can also try kayaking, water skiing, canoeing, or even swimming in Geist Lake’s crystal-clear waters.

DINING SELECTIONS: Get ready for a fantastic gastronomic adventure. There’s a whole strip of restaurants and cafes on all sides of the community. To start, wake up to Geist Coffee Company’s high-quality espresso and pair it with a cannoli at Kinsey’s Italian Cafe. For lunch, smack on pulled pork, brisket, and ribs at Trax B.B.Q., The Grill, or Woflies Grill – Geist. Reserve a private dinner in a sophisticated setting and enjoy red and white wines at Daniel’s Vineyard. Savor diverse food selections that will surely please your every craving.

Market Overview

McCordsville, IN Real Estate Information

Median Listing Price


Median Price Per Sq Ft


Average Days on Market


Median Price of Sold Homes


Home Ownership Percentage


Median Rent


Homes in Bay Creek at Geist, McCordsville, IN

5 Real Estate Facts About Homes for Sale in Bay Creek at Geist, McCordsville, IN

  • Homes for sale in Bay Creek, McCordsville, IN, have different floor plans, but all provide ample living space, ranging from 2,000 to 5,000 square feet.
  • Buyers can expect to spend $310,000 to $485,000 for single-family homes.
  • The generous lots measure from 0.24 to 0.33 acres.
  • These houses have functional floor layouts of two to four bedrooms and one to three bathroom combinations.
  • Dwelling places often feature an open floor plan, a huge patio, and an average two- to three-car garage.
On the map

Bay Creek at Geist, McCordsville, IN Map

US 36 and 234 are the main thoroughfares minutes away from Bay Creek at Geist. Olio Rd serves as a north-to-south road passing through the heart of the community. It is found southeast of Geist Reservoir. Villages of Brookside, Sagebrook, and Crystal Pointe are nearby neighborhoods.

Take the next step

Ready to take the next step?

Over the past 11 years, I’ve become a self-proclaimed real estate junkie who lives and breathes all things property related. I’ve spent these years focusing on familiarizing myself with every fact of real estate. Within the realm of the property world, I’ve flipped, wholesaled, lease optioned, and acquired a small portfolio of my own rentals. I am a progressive and forward-thinking Realtor with my approach to home sales, home buying, leasing, and new construction. My creativity and persistence benefit you as my client and I will utilize all of my skills to facilitate your transaction effectively and efficiently. I can be trusted to identify the best deal for you and your family. When you enlist me as your agent, you’ll directly benefit from the experience and expertise I will put to work for you.

Meet the locals

Who Lives in McCordsville, IN



Median Age


Median Household Income




Household size


Cost of living



Things to Do Near Bay Creek at Geist, McCordsville, IN

Daniel's Vineyard

The vineyard features a wide range of award-winning wines you can enjoy in the tasting room or on the outdoor patio overlooking the vineyard.

The Hawthorns Golf & Country Club

The club features a beautiful 18-hole golf course and a clubhouse with fine dining, a pro shop, and event spaces.

McCordsville Sports Park

The park includes several baseball and softball fields, soccer fields, playgrounds, walking trails, and picnic areas.


A popular local restaurant and bar with a diverse menu of American and international cuisine, craft cocktails, and a wide selection of beers and wines.


Schools Near Bay Creek at Geist, McCordsville, IN

School NameGradesAdmission
Geist Elementary SchoolK - 5Public
Mt. Vernon Middle School6 - 8Public
Mt Vernon High School9 - 12Public
Around Bay Creek at Geist, McCordsville, IN

People who like Bay Creek at Geist, McCordsville, IN also like